“The Plan of Salvation”: Five Finger Discount

Five Fingers

Walter Scott (1796-1861) was an evangelist who helped start the Restoration Movement. When coming to a new area, he told the children to raise their hands. Counting off one finger at a time, he explained that salvation consists of faith, repentance, baptism, forgiveness of sins, and receiving the Holy Spirit.

This became known as the “five finger exercise.” Christian churches still use it (in modified form) to explain the “plan of salvation.”

Even if you haven’t heard of the five finger exercise, you’ve probably heard of the “five finger discount.” This is a slang term for shoplifting. Someone gets this “discount” when they steal merchandise from a store.

The five finger exercise is helpful. Evangelists need to use simple, clear methods when presenting the gospel. And they should always call for a response. But without realizing it, Christians turn this exercise into a five finger discount. They rob the gospel of its value by making the five finger exercise their entire theology of salvation.

Discounting the Plan of Salvation
The five finger exercise is a useful evangelistic tool. But it is a mistake to use it as a theological tool. Unfortunately, this is what many Christians do. They use the exercise to summarize God’s entire “plan of salvation.” By doing so, they cause several problems.

First, they limit the “plan of salvation” to conversion. In other words, the plan consists entirely of how we respond to the gospel. Conversion is an important part of salvation. But it isn’t the whole plan.

Salvation isn’t a single point in time. It’s a process that spans all of human history. It began when God predestined us before creation (Ephesians 1:4). And it won’t end until He glorifies us at Jesus’ return (Philippians 3:20-21). The Bible suggests a larger scope and sequence for our salvation than the moment we become a Christian.

Second, the “five finger exercise” focuses exclusively on our response to the gospel. This implies that salvation depends on our initiative. In other words, we can decide to be saved without God’s help. He will only do His part after we do ours.

But the Bible is clear we cannot make that decision on our own. Apart from God’s enabling power, we could never receive Jesus in repentance and faith. We can only make the right response to the gospel if He produces that response within us.

Paul locates the initiative for our salvation in God: “For those God foreknew he also predestined…and those he predestined, he also called; those he called, he also justified; those he justified, he also glorified” (Romans 8:29-30). We don’t decide to be saved. Rather, God sets His saving plan in motion and moves us through each of its stages.

Securing the Plan of Salvation
Stores make every effort to protect their merchandise from the “five finger discount.” They install security cameras, hire security guards, and prosecute those caught stealing. In the same way, how can we protect the gospel against the “five finger exercise”? How can we keep it secure from the discounting tendencies of well-meaning Christians?

The best way is to appreciate its full scope and sequence as presented in Scripture. We must allow the Bible to expand our understanding of the “plan of salvation.” That is what this series is all about. Each post will progress through the successive stages of God’s saving plan. Be sure to subscribe to my blog to receive the entire series!

Feel free to share this post!

To receive my next post on predestination, subscribe by e-mail!

2 thoughts on ““The Plan of Salvation”: Five Finger Discount

  1. It feels like this is a case of never moving past the basics to a deeper understanding of the Gospel. We need something easy to grasp when talking to non-believers, but we are often times too lazy to move past that. I include myself in that group. “If it ain’t broke don’t fix it”, so we muddle through with a Sunday School type faith and a nagging feeling that something’s just not quite there instead of examining other ideas and looking at scripture as a whole.

    Anyway, good post.

    • Your comment reminds me of Hebrews 6: “Therefore let us leave the elementary teachings about Christ and go on to maturity” (v 1). We tend to ruminate on what we already know because it’s comfortable and familiar.

      But I think the blame lies more with pastors than church members. Paul goes on to clarify what he means by “elementary teachings”: “…not laying again the foundation of repentance…faith…instructions about baptisms” (vv 1-2).

      Repentance, faith, and baptism. In other words, conversion. Let us leave the basics about becoming a Christian and go on to maturity. Yet preachers present the same, simplistic gospel every week in their sermon invitations.

      Is it any wonder most Christians fail to grasp the full scope and sequence of their salvation?

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s